Headsail furling systems are ubiquitous, yet anyone who has to replace a damaged or worn-out system is faced with a bewildering range of options.

Granted, you could opt for the nearest like-for-like replacement, on the basis perhaps that there’s not likely to be much wrong with a system that has lasted for 20, 30 or even 40 years.

However, that may mean you’re buying a more expensive system than necessary.

Partially reefed genoa with poor sail shape. Credit: Rupert Holmes

For example there’s little point in paying a premium solely to get a double luff groove and removable drum if you never race fully crewed.

Having said that, twin grooves may be useful for setting twin poled out headsails for cruisers intending to cross the Atlantic.

Equally, automatically choosing a like-for-like replacement may mean you miss out on more recent developments that can improve sail shape and reliability.

Recent headsail furling developments

One of the more interesting of these is the Facnor FD (flat deck) that uses webbing at the drum rather than rope.

This allows for a lower-profile drum that increases the luff length of the sail, making it more efficient.

It also increases the mechanical advantage (ie leverage) when you first start furling, so the operation requires less effort.

The way the webbing leads onto the drum all but eliminates the risk of over-riding turns if the sail is unfurled too fast.

Yet at the cockpit end you handle a rope of a comfortable diameter, as with any other system.

This Facnor FD swivel joins the webbing to the rope that’s used to handle the furling line in the cockpit. Credit: Rupert Holmes

And the Torlon bearings require no maintenance other than regular rinses with fresh water.

These benefits mean that over the past five or six years it has become standard fit on many new yachts, particularly in the performance cruising sector.

Having used one myself for the past six years the only downside I’ve found is the need to replace the furling tape – usually every two or three years.

Seldén’s Furlex systems are well proven and, like the Facnor FD, start by taking bulk out of the middle of the sail, which helps improve shape when it’s part reefed.

Facnor FD uses webbing to furl rather than rope

The fourth generation version is 8% lighter, reducing weight aloft, and comes in five sizes for boats from 18ft up to 30 tonnes displacement.

It’s also available in electric and hydraulic models and with a below-deck drum.

Harken’s systems for boats from 22-80ft are also now in their fourth generation and feature large, low friction bearings along with independent tack and head swivels that allow the middle of the luff to furl first for an improved sail shape.

The company has recently added Ocean furlers to the range, which have a single groove round foil that makes for easier furling at the expense of a marginal aerodynamic loss when the sail is fully unfurled.

Ocean units also have a fixed tack swivel and drum that cannot be removed for racing.

Continues below…

How to set up your rig: tension your shrouds on masthead or fractional

How to set up your rig: tension your shrouds on masthead or fractional If boats were cars, many of those…

How to check your rigging

Maintenance of your rigging can save expensive failures and could be a lifesaver - here's how to check your boat's…

How to reef – expert advice from PBO Sail Clinic

How do you ensure an efficient reef with a roller-reefing headsail and slab-reefing mainsail? David Harding explains

Why won’t my boat tack properly?

David Harding offers ideas to help a Kelt 5.50 that won't beat upwind

I’ve also used Plastimo’s units, which have proved reliable over many years and can make a good budget option.

They are available in three sizes to suit boats from 14-36ft, with the largest retailing at well under £1,000.

However good your furling gear, it’s no secret that a deep reefed genoa will tend to set with a very inefficient shape.

Latest generation of Seldén’s Furlex 304S for boats up to 15 tonnes displacement

By the time a 130% or 140% overlapping headsail has been reefed down for strong winds a lot of the luff length is lost, which markedly reduces the sail’s efficiency.

In addition, the typical heavy UV strip on the luff and leech mean these areas gather bulk fastest as the sail is progressively reefed further and further.

This leads to a very deep shape in the middle of the luff, which leads to excessive heeling and weather helm.

Of course the effect can be reduced to some extent with foam (or rope) luff padding, furling systems that roll the centre of the sail first, and high tech sails with minimal stretch, but even then it can’t be eliminated in a deep reefed sail.

Twin forestays

Large bluewater yachts, typically those over 45ft, often have twin forestays with a genoa on the outer one and a smaller, higher aspect non-overlapping jib on the inner, with both set on roller furling gear.

This is an excellent arrangement that gives a large sail for light airs and reaching, plus one that will set efficiently in stronger winds and that’s easy to sheet in when short tacking.

Some new smaller performance cruisers have a similar arrangement, but use a free-flying furling sail on a halyard lock instead.

This means it can be rigged easily when needed, but is out of the way for the rest of the time.

Headsail furling gear for smaller boats: Plastimo 609 for boats from 20-30ft

Both these options would be clunky and expensive to retrofit on a smaller boat, but it’s relatively easy and inexpensive to replicate a similar set up using a removable Dyneema inner forestay.

Seldén sells a sensibly priced fitting for the mast for exactly this purpose.

The loads at the deck end of such a system should not be underestimated – on a 35ft boat a safe working load of several tonnes may be needed.

Therefore, simply bolting a fitting through the deck won’t suffice.

If you’re lucky enough to have a suitable bulkhead just back from the main forestay that can be used for a chainplate.

Alternatively, the deck fitting can be tied down to a fitting on the stem and tensioned using a bottlescrew or suitable purchase system.

Seldén’s Inner forestay fitting can be used with existing spars

There are two options for tensioning the stay on deck.

The neatest and cheapest is to take a 2:1 purchase back to a coachroof winch.

This also has the advantage of making it easy to set the inner forestay up at sea and the jib can be hanked on in advance so that it’s ready for use.

The other route is a large Highfield lever or adjustable bottlescrew – Seasure and Wichard respectively both have products for this purpose.

However, these can be difficult to fit when the boat is pitching in waves, so are best set up before leaving port on a breezy day.

This stay can be used for a hanked-on heavy weather jib (the size of a J3 or J4), or a storm jib.

If having a new sail made, it’s worth specifying it with extra reinforcement and a slab reef, which makes it easy to change down to a storm jib size sail without going onto the foredeck.

Enjoyed reading Headsail furling: how to choose the right system?

A subscription to Practical Boat Owner magazine costs around 40% less than the cover price.

Print and digital editions are available through Magazines Direct – where you can also find the latest deals.

PBO is packed with information to help you get the most from boat ownership – whether sail or power.

• • • • Take your DIY skills to the next level with trusted advice on boat maintenance and repairs
      • Impartial in-depth gear reviews
      • Practical cruising tips for making the most of your time afloat

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter